If you collected beanie babies back when they were a hot commodity and are ready to turn them into cash, you are in luck. We’ve found the best places to sell Beanie Babies.
Where to Sell Beanie Babies:
There are many places to sell Beanie Babies for top dollar. The best place to sell them will vary depending on the timing and demand. Whether you are looking for an online option, a selling app, or a local brick-and-mortar store, these are the best places to sell your Beanie Baby collection.
1. eBay
eBay is one of the best places to sell Beanie Babies because you can appeal to a niche audience using the right keywords. The platform is easy to use and has a high Apple App Store rating. That said, they charge listing and final value fees. Keep that in mind when you list your products. You can sell items on eBay at a fixed price or create an auction by setting the minimum bid. It’s even possible to set a reserve price to make a certain amount before accepting a sale. The site has the largest audience out of all the options on this list, so you’ll appeal to people worldwide. However, you should determine where you’ll ship to before creating your listing.
2. Bonanza
Bonanza is an online marketplace with a high Apple App Store rating. It lets you sell almost anything, including Beanie Babies. The site charges lower fees than other online options, like eBay. For example, it charges $0.25 for each item you sell and a 3.5% final value fee. Plus, you can use the same listings you used on other platforms, like eBay or Amazon, and integrate them into the Bonanza platform. Keep in mind that you’re responsible for shipping the items to the buyer, so include that cost in your prices to ensure you don’t lose money.
3. Collectible Stores
Depending on where you live, a few collectible stores might be interested in buying your Beanie Babies. Like antique stores, it’s best to find collectible stores specializing in toys for the best results. Consider getting quotes from several stores to see who can give you the best price. Since they operate as the middleman, these stores pay you less than you might get selling your Beanie Babies directly. As a result, you’ll want to choose the store that charges the fewest fees. Also, ensure you’ll be paid immediately when you sell to collectible stores. Some stores sell items on consignment, so you won’t get paid until the items sell. Depending on the demand for Beanie Babies in your area, this could take months.